Clan Carruthers

Clan Carruthers: Clan Gatherings and their Etiquette

40157742_2110723188938348_9198848658357878784_n.jpg
Three Good Friends of Clan Carruthers at a Gathering near Aberdeen, Scotland, all Armigers.

Highland Games, Gatherings and Festivals are events usually held from the Spring to the Autumn (Fall). They are designed to celibrate our Scottish culture, heritage and traditions, not only in Scotland but in such places as Australia, Canada, the US and in fact anyplace where groups of expats Scots or their descendants gather.

There are the usual forms of competitions and sporting events, synonymous with our history and culture, all carried out on the back drop of the skirl of the pipes, the beat of the drums and the whirl of the various kilts, displaying proudly their personal Scottish clan, society, band and heritage.

At the behest of some members we have decided to offer some basic advice on etiquette, in part taken from the works of Dr Bruce Drurie a well known Scottish heraldist and genealogist and Shenachie (Historian) to the lowland Clan Durie. The clan itself originating from along the forth estuary in Fife in Scotland.

This particular piece by him and offered in full, was taken from the Clans and Scottish Societies of Canada (CASSOC) website and although written for Scotland, it acts as a set of instructions for all respectable Gatherings, Festivals and Games who celebrate Scottish tradition and culture worldwide. Comments by the CCSI, relating to Carruthers or the current state of play, are offered in italics:

Clan Heraldry; What you can and Can’t wear and display

Highland games, gatherings, processions and so on are marvellous opportunities to show allegiance to a Clan, Family or Name, a feeling for heritage and support for all things Scottish. However, when In Scotland, all things heraldic and armorial are a matter of law – not just custom and practice – so it make sense to know what the rules are and how to obey them. 

1. If you don’t have a Coat of Arms, don’t display a Coat of Arms 

Few things cause more confusion and heated argument than Arms. 

Chiefs crest to badge

FACT: A Crest is not the same as Arms. The Crest is one component of Arms – it is the device originally worn on top of the helmet, and nowadays depicted above the escutcheon (the shield) or alone as a Crest Badge (see below). The Arms are usually shown either as just the shield or as the full “achievement” of shield, helmet-wreath-mantling, crest, motto and (if any) supporters. 

IMG_0354
Arms of the Chief of Carruthers.

FACT: There is NO SUCH THING as a “Family Coat of Arms” in Scotland – Arms are the personal, heritable property of one person and just because you share a surname does NOT mean you can use these Arms, any more than you could drive away in that person’s car.

MAKE NO MISTAKE – these matters are regulated by Statute Law in Scotland and there are real penalties, including fines, confiscation and ultimately jail, for “pretending to Arms” that are not yours. 

FACT: A Clan or Family may have a number of Armigers (people legally entitled to bear Arms) but the “undifferenced” Arms will typically be borne by the Chief of that Name.

(Currently Carruthers has no Chief, but after petitions and documentation have been presented, we await the Lord Lyons Proclamation on the same to confirm the right for a Carruthers of the senior line to bear the chiefly Arms. CCSI )

BOTTOM LINE: Unless you personally have been granted Arms by Lord Lyon, do not display Arms. If an ancestor of yours had Arms, by all means apply to have these re-matriculated in your name (consult www.lyon-court.com). This is the process that the Society is going through the Lyon court to achieve, but in this case they are the Chiefs Arms. (CCSI).

YOU CAN WEAR OR DISPLAY THE CREST

carruthers-clansman-s-badge
Crest of Carruthers

Any kinsman/kinswoman of an armigerous Chief of Name and Arms may wear a device bearing the Chief’s Crest. Typically this will be a strap-and-buckle design, worn as a cap-badge, kilt-pin, plaid brooch etc. and used as a graphic image (on literature, merchandise and the like). In theory, the Crest belongs to the Chief (or senior Armiger) and properly, permission should be sought and fealty sworn. But informally, most Chiefs are only too happy to see as many people as possible wearing the Crest Badge.

The Chief, by the way, wears the Crest inside a simple circlet, with three eagle feathers. Chieftains and the heir of the Chief wear two feathers. Armigers of that name wear a single feather. 

From left to right: Chief, Heir to the Chief and Armiger

2. Clan or Family?

This is the other great bone of contention. Not every name in Scotland is attached to a Clan. The Clan is a Highland phenomenon – but by extension the term Clan is applied to those Borders families who were organised and behaved as Clans. Names from the Lowlands are considered to be in Families. Bruce is not a Clan. Douglas is not a Clan. Wallace is not a Clan. Wood is not a Clan. 

The “Lowlands”, by the way, includes some areas quite far north in Scotland – the non-mountainous areas of Angus, Aberdeenshire, Nairnshire and so on. Roughly, draw a line north-east from Dumbarton to Aboyne, then north to about Aberlour, and north-west to Nairn – anything to the left of that is Highlands.

There is a list of Clans, as defined at the point where many of their jurisdictional powers were taken away, taken from the Acts of Parliament 1587 & 1594. There’s a corresponding map with Possessions of the Highland Proprietors at  http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_the_clans_of_Scotland_(1899,_third_edition).jpg

Note; Carruthers do not see themselves as a lowland name per se, but proudly see themselves as belonging to those Riding Families or Reivers from the Scottish Borders and in our case the West March (Annandale, Dumfrisshire).

As much as some border familiies do not see themselves as Clans, Carruthers was one of 17 named border clans in the 1587 Act of the Scottish Parliament of unruly clans, it is therefore a personal choice (CCSI)

A Clan or Family which has a recognised Chief or other head has “noble” status, legally recognised and with a corporate identity. A Family or Name group with no recognised chief has no official position in Scots law. 

Douglas, for instance, having no Chief, can never be a Clan – it is subsumed under Hamilton (Chief, His Grace Alexander, 16th Duke Of Hamilton) and the last Chief of Clan Douglas (Archibald, 1st Duke of Douglas) died in 1761. 

Under the present Lyon, if Douglas chose to either prove their genealogy or alternatively hold a derbfine both under the auspices of the Lord Lyon, they may on confirmation of either a Commander or Chief, attain Clan status.

Carruthers awaits, after 12 years with all the paperwork submitted, the decision on a Carruthers Chief through confirmation of Arms by the Lord Lyon (CCSI)

In any case, the ancient clan system more or less went away after the Clans Act and other laws of the immediate post-1745 period, and the remnant of it we know today was re-created in the first quarter of the 19th century, largely by the enthusiasm of Sir Walter Scott and the visit to Edinburgh he organised for King George IV in 1822. 

LORD LYON DOES NOT REGULATE CLANS 

When Lord Lyon grants Arms to a Chief, the Letters Patent may say something like: “Angus McSneckie of McSneckie, Chief of the Name and Arms of Clan McSneckie” but this merely acknowledges that the Clan exists, not that Lord Lyon has conferred “Clan” status. Lyon exercises no jurisdiction over what is or is not considered a “Clan”, but can offer advice on how a Clan or Family can go about appointing or recognising a Chief after a Family Convention or Derbhfine. There are roughly 140 Clans and Names that have Chiefs recognised by the Lord Lyon.

What does the Lyon do

The Court of the Lord Lyon King of Arms is the national heraldic authority for Scotland & Scots abroad.The Lyon themselves, arethe head of the Court, and is the most junior of the Great Officers of State in Scotland. They are the Scottish officer with responsibility for regulating heraldry relating to that country, matriculating old and issuing new grants of arms, and serving as the Legal authority on the matter. The Lyon Court is the oldest heraldic court in the world that is still in daily operation.

The historic title of the post was the High Sennachie, and he was given the title of Lord Lyon from the lion in the coat of Arms of Scotland.

The Lyon, therefore is the only person with the authority to confirm the right of an individual, after careful examination of the documentation and evidence, to bear the chiefly arms of a clan or family. This legal process accepts them as chief of that name. This in itself takes the clan from armigerous or unofficial status to official status and recognition, which is what our society has been working on for 12 years and more. (CCSI)

Standing Council of Scottish Chiefs 

Recognised Chiefs can belong to the Standing Council of Scottish Chiefs of Clans and Names (SCSC – www.clanchiefs.org) but be aware that this body does not regulate Clans and Families, nor is it an umbrella body for Clan and Family Societies. 

iu-9The Standing Council of Scottish Chiefs is the definitive and authoritative body for information on the Scottish Clan System. Within the website you will find information relating to the Standing Council, as well as links to other relevant resources, together with additional information on the Clan system. Their lists of reconised chiefs of officially recognised clans can be found here. https://www.clanchiefs.org.uk/chief/ (CCSI)

  Mc or Mac? 

Mc is Irish and Mac is Scottish. Or is it the other way round? Actually, it’s neither – McNaewhere (and for that matter M’Naewhere) are just abbreviations for MacNaewhere. The Mc or Mac form may have become fixed over time in one particular branch, but it does not signify origin. Also, don’t fret over variants – a McKay is a MacKay is a M’Kay is a McCay is a Mackey is a Makee is a Makey, and all are derived from MacHugh (Gaelic, MacAoidh). 

3. Banners, Pennants and Standards – get it right

img-1300_orig
Flag of the Arms of a Chief (once confirmed) of Carruthers

Planning to fly a flag or carry a “banner” of some sort at a Gathering in Scotland? Lovely idea, but do get it right. Almost all forms of flag are personal to the Armiger, just like Arms. 

flags.png
Lion Rampant (left) and Saltire (right)

DO NOT FLY THE LION RAMPANT – FLY THE SALTIRE

First of all, the Lion Rampant is part of the Arms of the Sovereign and the Great Officers of State of Scotland. It is the personal Banner of the King or Queen of Scots and is NOT the Scottish flag. That’s the Saltire. DO NOT display the Lion Rampant, unless you’re fortunate enough to have the Queen, the First Minister, the Lord Lyon etc. in your tent at the time!

Standard of the Chief of Clan Sinclair

Standard – an elongated shape, tapering from 1.2 m down to 60 cm, with the fly edge split and rounded (lanceolate). The length is according to rank, from 7.5 m for the Sovereign down to 3.5 m for a Knight, Baron or Chief. It bears the Arms as on the shield, with the tail parted per fess with the Crest, Badge and/or Supporter, plus the motto on one or more Ribands. The Standard is set before the Chief’s tent (as it’s a “Headquarters” flag and does not indicate that the Armiger is in residence) rather than carried like the banner. A Standard requires a separate grant by the Lord Lyon and is only made under certain conditions.

Guidon of MacGillivray of Dunmaglass

Guidon – one-third shorter than a Standard and tapering to a round, unsplit end at the fly. These are assigned by Lord Lyon to individuals who have Supporters to their Arms, and to others who have a following – those in a position of leadership or some official position.

Duncan (1).jpg
Duncan of Sketraw Pennon

Pennon – a smaller, elongated flag 4 ft long with a pointed, rounded or swallow-tailed end, designed to be displayed on a lance, assigned by Lord Lyon King to an Armiger who applies for one. It is charged with the personal heraldic badge or some other armorial ensign of the owner.

 

Pincel of Barclay

Pennoncelle or Pincel – a modification of this, 1.3 m long x 60 cm high at the hoist and tapering away to a point, bearing the Crest Badge and perhaps the Motto on the livery colours. This is flown by anyone officially representing or delegated by the Chief, so tents at gatherings and games usually fit the bill. HOWEVER, it is allotted only to Chiefs or particular Chieftain-Barons only upon the specific authority of Lord Lyon.

Parade Banner, Grant

Banner – a square or rectangular upright representation of the Arms designed for carrying in warfare or tournaments, but now flown as a “house flag” when the Armiger is in residence and is NOT the flag of the Clan or Family. Originally, conspicuous gallantry in battle was marked by cutting off the tail of the Standard or Pennon, turning it into a Banner. Strictly speaking, the sizes and shapes are:

Square banner – Sovereign, 1.5 m square; Dukes; 1.25 m sq; Earls, 1.1 m sq; Viscounts and Barons, 1 m sq; Baronets and feudal barons, 0.9 m sq; other Armigers, 70 cm wide x 85 cm high

Rectangular banner – typically in the ratio 3:2, or 5:4 when flown as the “house flag” of an Armiger.

Carrying flag – this should be sized as follows (width x height): Peers, 1.2 m x 1.5 m; Feudal Barons, 90 cm x 115 cm; Chiefs, 85 cm x 110 cm; Chieftains, 80 cm x 90 cm.

The Gonfalon of Durie

Gonfalon – a vertically-hung banner bearing the Coat of Arms, widely used in processions and carried before the Armiger (such as the Chief).

Ensign – small, decorated (often with a gold fringe) of the livery colours, bearing the full Achievement of Arms, usually on a stiff backing. These are seen, for example, on stall-plates.

Table banner – similar to an Ensign, but designed for an Armiger to put on the dinner-table.

Otherwise, get a Pincel made showing ONLY the Chief’s Crest Badge.

There is more (official!) guidance at www.lyon-court.com/lordlyon/375.html, but notice that all references to “square metres” should be to “metres square”

Pipe banner – rather similar to a Banner, but of a size to fit on the longest drone of the pipes (usually 45 cm) and richly decorated with gold fringing, tassles and the like. The pipe banner for a Chief who is also a Peer or a Feudal Baron should have a rounded end extending beyond the length, and any other Chief a split rounded end.

40600212_2113528665641070_317078709406269440_n.jpg
Armigers with their flags outside Broomhall with Charles, Lord Bruce

SO WHAT CAN WE USE ON OUR TENT OR IN A PROCESSION?

The bottom line is – all these “flags” are meant to represent the Armiger, and must have been granted by the Lord Lyon. If your Chief is there, by all means fly his or her Banner or Pennon. If the tent is a temporary “Headquarters” of your Chief, display the Banner. If delegated, fly a Pincel with the authority of (and as a sign of fealty to) your Armigerous Chief.

4. Tartan and Highland Wear

Which Tartan?

img_1244
Bruce and Carruthers Tartan, side ny side, with the Clan Badge in the middle

Essentially, wear what you like, within the limits of good taste and polite behaviour. Tartans are not regulated in the way that Arms are, although there is an official Register of Tartans maintained by the Keeper of Tartans, who is the same person as the Keeper of the Records of Scotland and Registrar-General (www.tartanregister.gov.uk). The Register contains those designs accepted, but of course new tartans are being designed all the time.

Do not confuse this with commercial organisations such as the soi-disant Scottish Tartans Authority – a fine resource in its own right, but not official in any way.

Also, just because some weaving company decides to advertise “The Ancient McSomething” does not necessarily mean it is either “ancient” or anything at all to do with the McSomethings, who may not even know of its existence.

In any case, many so-called “ancient” tartans were picked from existing pattern books around 1822, and most Lowland (or Border) Families would never have had a tartan anyway.

ALL tartans are registered and recorded based on their pattern rather than a name eg; Ancient, hunting, old, modern etc, as alluded to above. These patterens or setts are held in the Register of Tartans in Edinburgh Scotland.

Bruce for instance has around 15 registered tartans, some private, some free to use by the clan. If in doubt regarding ownersip of a tartan, check they have their colours and thread count recorded. This will to eliminate false claims. What this means is simply, that although Carruthers may continue to wear Bruce, we cannot claim it as our own (CCSI).

9ef111c8-ab15-4b3a-be65-073c08bdffd2
Carruther Red Tartan

         Ladies’ sash

It may not come up, but if attending a formal event, a lady may wish to wear her surname tartan or that of her husband, as a sash. But take care not to send the wrong message by draping it over the wrong shoulder. The basic rules, as approved by Lord Lyon, are:

1) over the left shoulder, brooch at shoulder – female Chiefs, wives of Chiefs and Colonels of the Scottish Regiment, Heads of companies, but also Highland Dancers (to keep the right arm free), 

2) over the right shoulder, brooch at shoulder – almost everyone else, except…

3) over the right shoulder, with a bow on the left hip – ladies who have married out of their Clan or Family but wish to wear their original Name tartan.

Clan or Family Crest Badge

img_3055Wear the Chief’s badge proudly, as a kilt-pin, cap-badge, fly-plaid clasp or brooch.

4. Weapons

iu.jpegLet’s be very, very clear here – it is ILLEGAL to go about in public in Scotland, and in fact other countries armed with sharp implements. And let’s not have any nonsense about “our ancient right to bear weapons” or other fictions – your rights are precisely what the law says your rights are, and the law says – DON’T.

There is an exception – a blade of length less than 3.5 inches worn as part of ethnic dress is exempt from the Knife Act [1], but only if kept sheathed. Anything longer – and any knife at all if brandished about – becomes an offensive weapon in the eyes of the law and, if in Scotland could get you four years in prison and a fine of £5,000. Most of us choose to wear a fake ceremonial sgian dubh in the sock, just for show.

Indoors, in private, is a different matter, but most clubs, pubs etc. will not allow any weapon on the premises, kilt or no kilt.

The Scottish Police are generally sensible about such things at processions, games and so on, but there is an increasing trend for them to take a zero-tolerance stance and just ask everyone to disarm. Right now. Or else.

Anyone attempting to bring a metallic weapon into the country will find it gets confiscated at airport security.

Applying for Arms

If you would like to apply for Arms, have your genealogy investigated or need documents transcribed/translated, visit www.brucedurie.co.uk. 

Alternatively, for Arms design, one may use the services of Mr Anthony Maxwell of Edinburgh, who is both a superb heraldic artist and can walk through through the application. https://www.facebook.com/AnthonyMaxwellHeraldicIllustrator/

Publications

You may also be interested in the most authoritative guide to such matter – J H Stevenson’s “Heraldry in Scotland”. This two-volume 1915 work is now available in a single-volume hardback edition from www.brucedurie.co.uk/books

[1] The Criminal Law (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 1995 Sec. 49, Sub-sec. 5(c) and in England and Wales, the Criminal Justice Act 1988 (section 139)[7] and the Offensive Weapons Act 1996 (section 3 and 4).

Examples of the Full Achievement of Arms; on the left Dr George Carruthers KCHT, KEG, OLJ, CStN, FSAScot and on the right Mr Ronald Watt OBE, ORS, KHT

These guidlines were written by Prof. Bruce Durie, BSc (Hons) PgCertAAS PhD FSAScot FHEA FIGRS FCollT OLJ, with pieces in italics, pertainent to Carruthers in Italics, by the CCSI

GC BADGE ARTWORK Chosen Logo-10CCSI

Promptus et Fidelis     

 

 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.